What Does Practice Do? Yoga Sutras 1.40 to 1.51

Everything we think do or say creates karma; impressions that color the world and make us see it as we think it is, or how we want it to be, rather than as it truly exists. The point of practice is to become like a gardener and weed out these seeds, to be able to see the world as neutral. As Shakespeare said, “There is nothing that is good or bad, but thinking makes it so.” Whether we see something as good or bad is dependent on our karma, or which seeds are ripening at any particular time. One of the easiest books to read about seeds is How Yoga Works, by Geshe Michael Roche.

Y.S. 1.40 Paramanu paramamahattvantah asya vasikarah
Paramanu an infinitesimal, a particle, an atom
paramamahattvantah most distant, most excellent,highest, best, greatest
asya of this
vasikarah bringing into subjugation, havinf mastery over passions, or in one’s power

This sutra describes how the ordinary mind is transformed into a super-mind, where nothing is beyond comprehension. The mind can follow and understand then simple and the complex, the infinite and the infinitesimal, the perceptible and the imperceptible.

Y.S. 1.41 Ksinavrtteh abhijatatasya iva maneh grahitr grahanagrahyesutatstha tadanjanata samapattih
Ksina dissolving of the gunas: tamas, rajas and sattva
vrtteh modifications, fluctuations
abhijatatasya inborn, noble, courteous, polite
iva like
maneh a gem, flawless crystal
grahitr knower, taker, perceiver
grahana act of seizing, catching, accepting
grahyesu to be known
tatstha becoming stable
tadanjanata acquiring or taking the shape of the seen or the known
samapattih transformation, assuming the original form, consummation

When the mind is free from distraction, it is possible for all the mental processes to be involved in the object of inquiry. As one remains in this state, gradually one becomes immersed in the object. The mind then, like a flawless diamond, reflects only the features of the object and nothing else. The yogi realizes that the knower, the instrument of knowing and the known are one, himself, the seer.

Y.S. 1.42 Tatra sabdartha jnana vikalpaih samkirna savitarka samapattih
Tatra there
sabda word
artha purpose, aim, meaning
jnana knowing, knowledge, intelligence
vikalpaih an option, imagination, the act of allowing a rule to be observed or not as one pleases
samkirna poured together, mixed together
savitarka becoming totally engrossed, thoughtful
samapattih transformation

At this stage, called savitarka samapatti, the word, meaning and content are blended and become special knowledge

Y.S. 1.43 Smrti parisuddhau svarupasunya arthamatra nirbhasa nirvitarka
Smrti memory
parisuddhau completely cleansed, purest of minds
svarupasunya devoid of one’s nature
iva as it were
arthamatranirbhasa shining alone in purest form
nirvitarka unreflecting, unconsidered, without analysis or logic

In nirvitarka samapatti, the difference between memory and intellectual illumination is disclosed, memory is cleansed and consciousness shines without reflection. The mind becomes crystal clear and at one with the object. At this moment there is no feeling of oneself. This is pure perception.

Y.S. 1.44 Etayaiva savicara nirvicara ca suksma visaya vyakhyata
Etaya by this
eva also
savicara reflection, deliberation, consideration, investigation
nirvicara without reflection, not needing any consideration
ca and
suksmavisaya subtle object, subtle thing
vyakhyata related, explained, expounded, commented upon.

The contemplation of subtle aspects is similarly explained as deliberate, savicara samapatti or non-deliberate nirvicara samapatti

Y.S. 1.45 Suksma visayatvam ca alinga paryavasanam
Suksma subtle
visayatvam object
ca and
alinga having no characteristic mark, unmanifested form
paryavasanam ending

The subtlest level of nature is consciousness. When consciousness dissolves in nature, it loses all marks and becomes pure. By exploring the subtle particles of nature, consciousness reaches its goal. This is the state of the cessation of the fluctuations of the mind which is mentioned in the second Sutra. This state is considered to be the crossroads of Self-Realization.

Y.S. 1.46 Ta eva sabijas samadhih
Ta they
eva only
sabijas with seed
samadhih profound meditation or absorption

The states of Samadhi described in the previous sutras are dependent upon a support or seed and are termed sabija. These states are dependent on an object which includes the intelligence (buddhi) and the “I” principle (asmita). Their seed is the core of the being.
The six samapattis mentioned so far belong to functions of the brain. The source of analysis (savitarka) or absence of analysis (nirvitarka)is the frontal brain. For investigation and examination (savicara) or absence of them (nirvicara) the source is the back of the brain. The source of joy (ananda) is the base of the brain and of individuality (asmita) the top of the brain.

Through the disciplines of yoga, the practitioner (sadaka) transforms his attention from the gross to the subtle. When he reaches the apex of nature, the brain being a part of nature, he attains perfection in controlling the modes of consciousness. He is able to sop all functions of the brain, deliberate and non-deliberate at will. That is why it is termed Samadhi with seed.

Is it possible for an individual to reach this state of yoga? Yes, but it is important that they prepare themselves carefully, that they commit to steady practice and sustained interest to make progress. Without preparation there can be no foundation. And without gradual progression, the human system may react and rebel.

Y.S. 1.47 nirvicara vaisaradye dhyatma prasadah
nirvicara non-reflection, or reflection without seeds
vaisaradye I skillfulness, profound knowledge
dhyatma supreme soul (manifested as an individual soul) the relation between the supreme and individual soul
prasadah clearness, brightness

From proficiency in nirvicara samapatti comes purity. Sattva or luminosity flows undisturbed, kindling the spiritual light of the self. Or, then the individual begins to truly know himself.

Y.S. 1.48 rtambhara tatra prajna
rtambhara upholding truth, full of truth
tatra therein
prajna faculty of insight, wisdom

When consciousness dwells in wisdom, a truth-bearing state of direct spiritual perception dawns. What the practitioner sees and shares with others is free from error.

Y.S. 1.49 Sruta anumana prajna abhyam anya visaya visesa arthatvat
Sruta heard, listened or ascertained
anumana inference, conjecture
prajnabhyam from the wisdom of insight
anyavisaya other object
visesa peculiar, distinguishing between, special property
arthatvat object, purpose, aim, end

Knowledge is no longer based on memory or inference. It is spontaneous, direct and at a level and intensity that is beyond the ordinary.

Y.S. 1.50 Tajjas samskarro anyasamskara pratibandhi
Tajjas Born or sprung from
samskarro conception, instinct, formation in the mind, impressions acquired by effort are subliminal (samskara), and recollecting them is an impression or memory.
anyasamskara other impressions, other conceptions or formations
pratibandhi contradicting, objecting, impeding

A new life begins with this truth-bearing light. Previous impressions are left behind and new ones are prevented.

Y.S. 1.51 Tasyapi nirodhe sarva nirodhat nirbijah Samadhi
Tasyapi that too
nirodhe by shutting, closing, restraining, destroying, by cessation
sarva all
nirodhat checking, suppressing, destrouing
nirbijah seedless
Samadhi profound meditation

When that new light of wisdom is also relinquished, seedless Samadhi dawns.
The practitioner must learn to restrain even this new impression of truth-bearing light. When both old and new impressions are dissolved, a state of seedless enlightenment arises, in which all allusions and delusions terminate. This is nirbijah Samadhi, the state of absolute identity with the seer. This is the ultimate state of Samadhi.

Such comprehension is not sought. It comes inevitably and nothing can stop it. This state cannot be described in words. Only those who have reached this state can comprehend it.

The Yoga Sutras – 1.33– 1.39 Examples of Practice to Still Your Mind

We think we know the nature of our minds, but by reading through this first chapter of the Yoga Sutras, it is clear to me that unless we understand how the mind works, we are at its mercy.

My foray into the Yoga Sutras has been very enlightening.  I see this text as the origin of a lot of the tidbits of information I know about yoga; things that I say and often believe in, but never knew exactly where this knowledge came from.   It is interesting to see where I am on the path of yoga and validating to see how far I have come.  It is also humbling to see the stumbling blocks that these threads so clearly expose!

This part of the Sutras is a continuation of the practices to help you develop a tranquil mind.    In summary these practices include:

1.33  Being pleased with others who are happier than ourselves, compassionate toward those who are unhappy, joyful with those who are doing praiseworthy things and undisturbed by the errors of others.  This is one of those simple but not easy practices!  Some of the rest of these practices are things that you actually have to do, like meditate or practice pranayama.  But all you have to do to practice this sutra is to live your life and be out in the world among others.  Can you be happy for those who got their power back before you did after the snowstorm last week?  Or maybe even be really happy for those who never lost power in the first place?  Maybe you notice how irate you get at another driver who is doing something “wrong”.    Or, there is the German word schadenfreude which means to derive pleasure from someone else’s pain.  All of these things cause our minds to lose their tranquility.

1.34  Pranayama or regulation of the breath.  The breath is the greatest indicator of the state of the mind.  It is connected to both the sympathetic and the parasympathetic nervous system.  This means that your breath is both part of your conscious and unconscious mind.  By focusing on the breath you can relax your mind and by noticing the breath, you have a reliable witness to your state of mind.

1.35  By truly being present with whatever experience you are having, focusing on your senses and your direct experience.  In other words, don’t multi-task. Try being present the whole time while peeling an eating an orange.  In his book, Into the Magic Shop, author and neurosurgeon James Doty writes that we are not present and lose our attention on average 6 times a minute!

1.36  By meditating on the creative expression of peace/God/love/light/oneness within you.  This is the practice of connecting to something higher than yourself and seeing our inter-connectedness as a whole.

1.37  By contemplating enlightened sages who have walked this path before us, or by simply emulating a person you respect and admire.

1.38   By paying attention to your dreams. Dreaming is another state of consciousness and it is possible to harness the power of your dreams. Practitioners of lucid dreaming say that you can use this technique as a tool for problem solving, self-healing, and personal growth.

1.39  By meditating deeply on one thing, it is possible to extrapolate about other things.  Here Patanjali gives us permission to study and meditate on any object of our choosing,  One of my yoga students once told me that a teacher told him that he was meditating wrong.  While he may have been meditating in a different way from that teacher's lineage, I don't believe that, if you are meditating, you can be doing it incorrectly.  Patanjali also counsels us to stick with whatever method of meditation we have chosen and not waste time by trying many different things.  This is the concept of digging one 100 foot deep hole rather than digging one hundred 1 foot deep holes.  This sutra relates to the concept of mastery being the equivalent of putting in 10,000 hours of work and study.  It also counsels us to practice restraint by being aware of  the arrogance that can come along with the great gift of knowledge and practice.  This means that just because we can perform advanced asana or we don't eat certain things, that we should not hold that out as our being superior over others.

Yoga Sutras 1.33 – 1.37 The Yoga Sutras on Examples of Practice

These sutras teach us about how to practice.  One of the important concepts to be aware of are the qualities of nature and of the mind.  These qualities are called the gunas; they are cosmic energies that pervade all of nature.  There are three qualities of nature: rajas, or the energy of activity, change, evolution and development.  In the mind rajas is the energy attachment, wanting, grasping and desire;  it is the fight of the fight, flight or freeze response.   Without rajas we would never get anywhere.

The next quality of nature is tamas which means inertia or lack of movement.  In the mind it is stubbornness, resistance to change, apathy or a feeling of being “stuck”.   Tamas represents that tendency to freeze, the reluctance to trying something new.

Sattva is the point of balance between rajas and tamas.  At the level of the mind, sattva is a balance of clarity and light.  Sattva is a feeling of peace, balance and harmony, a sense of being enough, doing enough and having enough.  If our practices are too rajasic, they will be too harsh and austere.  If too tamasic, they will never get off the ground; we will be too lazy, or we won't try something new because we "have always done it that way".  One way to tell if our practices are working is if they create a sense of sattvic balance.

Y.S. 1.33 Maitri karuna mudito peksanam sukha dukha punya apunya visayanam bhavantah citta prasadanam

Maitri – friendliness
karuna – compassion, mercy
mudita – gladness, joy
upeksanam – to be indifferent and apathetic, to look at things without interest
sukha – happiness
dukha – sorrow
punya – virtue
apunya – vice
visayanam – regarding an object, concerning a thing
bhavantah – conception, remembrance, infusion, recollection, thoughtfulness
cittaprasadanam – graceful diffusion of the consciousness, favorable disposition

In daily life we see people around us who are happier than we are and people who are less happy.  Some may be doing praiseworthy things and others causing problems.  Whatever may be our usual attitude toward such people and their actions, if we can be pleased with others who are happier than ourselves, compassionate toward those who are unhappy, joyful with those who are doing praiseworthy things and remain undisturbed by the errors of others, our mind will be very tranquil.

What this means in our daily life: If we can be happy when others are happy, then we can experience happiness more frequently.  If we can overlook the mistakes of others, then we know that our own transgressions can be forgiven.  Also, the act of doing good is its own reward.  We do not need praise or recognition for doing the right thing.

Y.S. 1.34  Pracchardana vidharana abhyam va pranasya

Pracchardana – emitting, sending forth, discharging, expelling, exhalation
vidharanabhyam –restraining, maintaining, supporting, executing
va – or, an option, also the power of choosing correctly, selection, alternatively
pranasya- of breath

When we find interruptions in mental clarity:
The practice of breathing exercises involving extended exhalation may be helpful:

One should inhale and exhale slowly and pause, maintaining the retention for as long as is comfortable.  This practice ensures a state of consciousness which is like a calm lake.

What this means in your daily life:  The breath is the greatest indicator of the state of the mind.  When the breath is not smooth and regular, something is disturbing us.   Find out what that is and deal with it and the breath should be able to return to a smooth and regular rhythm.

Y.S. 1.35  Visayavati va pravrttih utpanna manasah sthiti nibandhini

Visayavati – related to, attached to object, that which is perceived
va - or
pravrttih – moving onwards, advancing, progressing, contemplating, devoting, applying
utpanna – born, produced, acquired, accomplished
manasah - mind
sthiti - state
nibandhini – origin, basis, foundation, binding together,

By regular inquiry into the role of the senses we can reduce mental distortions.  Or, by contemplating an object that helps to maintain steadiness of mind and consciousness.

What this means in your daily life:  Use a tool to help you meditate.  It can be a mantra, your breath, an altar on which you set meaningful objects and symbols of your devotion or the ritual of lighting a candle.  But do set up a routine that helps you turn inward on a regular basis.

Y.S. 1.36  Visoka va jyotismati

Visoka – free from grief, sorrowless effulgent light
va  - or
jyotismati – luminous, bright, shining, possessed of luminous bodies, a tranquil state of mind

When we inquire into what life is and what keeps us alive, we may find some solace for our mental distractions.
Consideration of things greater than ourselves helps us put ourselves into perspective.

Here, the concentration is on the innermost core of the heart, wherein alone the sorrow-less, effulgent light glows.  That is the seat of the soul.  The mind is guided in such a way that it becomes engrossed and penetrates toward its source.  Movements in the form of thoughts in the mind are waves, and citta, or the seat of consciousness, is the ocean.  The sadaka, practitioner, must learn to keep the citta motionless and thoughtfully silent, without creating waves of thought.  This effort or stilling and silencing the citta brings forth the sorrow-less effulgent light of the soul.

What this means in your daily life: You are sitting to meditate and there is some noise outside, someone is working or mowing the lawn and it is disturbing your meditation practice, or your peace.  In reality, this is not someone who is doing something to you, they are simply mowing their lawn.  It has nothing to do with your meditation practice, or your peace.  In fact, the noise is part of your meditation practice.  You can choose to meditate later, or you can welcome the sound of mowing into your practice.  The problem is that we want the world to operate according to our personal agenda and when it doesn't, we get upset; it distracts us mentally.   We blame the noise on our inability to concentrate, when in fact the noise is simply a test of our concentration.

For those of you who are interested in the texts I have been using, I base my commentary on The Yoga Sutras from a combination of several texts and one app:
The Heart of Yoga by T.K.V. Desikachar
Light on The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by B.K.S. Iyengar
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Edwin F. Bryant
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Swami Satchidananda
And an app on the Yoga Sutras developed by Daniel Levine

Yoga Sutras 1.29 – 1.32 – The Obstacles on the Path to Enlightenment

Y.S. 1.29 Tatah pratyakcetana adhigamah api antarya abhavah ca
tatah – then
pratyakcetana – individual soul, introspective mind
adigamah – to find, discover
api – also, too
antarya – obstacle
abhavah – absence
ca – and

Meditation on god with the repetition of Om removes obstacles to the mastery of the inner self
Chanting and surrendering to a higher power helps you tune into that cosmic power. By that turning inward and tuning in you imbibe all of those qualities, get the cosmic vision, transcend all of your limitations and finally become that transcendent reality. Normally you are limited by your body and your mind, but by holding something infinite you slowly raise yourself from the finite objects that bind you and you transcend them. Through that you get rid of all of the obstacles and your path is made easy! Ah, but what are those obstacles? Patanjali tells us in the next Sutra:

Y.S. 1.30 Vyadhi styana samsaya pramada alasya avirati bhrantidarsana alabdhabhumikatva anavasthitavani cittaviksepah te antaryah
Vyadhi – disease
styana – mental laziness
samsaya – doubt, indecision
pramada – intoxication, carelessness
alasya – physical laziness
avirati – lacking in moderation or control
bhrantidarsana – living under illusion
alabhdabhumikatva – missing the point, inability to hold on to what is achieved
anavasthitavani – an unsettled state
cittaviksepah – a scattered mind
te – these
antarayah – obstacles, impediments

These 9 obstacles can be divided into physical, mental, intellectual and spiritual categories:
Physical
a. disease
b. lack of interest or sluggishness, physical laziness

Mental
a. Lingering doubt
b. Pride or carelessness
c. Idleness, mental laziness
d. Sense gratification, lacking moderation or control

Intellectual
a. Living in a world of delusion

Spiritual
a. Lack of perseverance or not being able to hold on to what has been undertaken
b. Inability to maintain the progress attained due to pride or stagnation in practices

These obstacles are like a chain: the first obstacle is physical disease. We all know that if you are not healthy, everything else is difficult. Disease makes you dull and a dull mind will doubt everything because it doesn’t have the energy to penetrate something in order to understand it.

When there is doubt, there is a carelessness, lethargy and laziness. When the mind loses interest towards a higher goal, it has to do something else so it will slowly descend to the sensual enjoyments. These obstacles could be summed up as the qualities of tamas which means inertia or dullness.

One of the main obstacles is slipping from the ground one has gained. This one obstacle is a big impediment for many people. A beginner will practice with intense interest. Everyday she will feel more and more interested and feel she is progressing steadily. She may even be proud of her progress. All of a sudden, one day she will find that she has lost everything and slipped down to rock bottom.
This happens to everyone. If we know it is a common occurrence, we won’t get disheartened. Otherwise we will lose all hope and interest and stop practicing all together. But this is just a test. Please know that this is common in the case of every aspirant. The mind can’t function on the same level always; it has its highs and lows. If there is going to be steady progress always, there will be no challenge, no game in it.

Y.S. 1.31 Duhkha daurmanasya angamejayatva svasapprasvasah viksepa shabhuvah

Duhkha – sorrow, pain
daurmansaya – mental pain, despair
angamejayatva – unsteadiness of the body
svasapprasvasah – inspiration and expiration
viksepa – scattered, causing distraction
shabhuvah – concurrent

Sorrow, despair, unsteadiness of the body and irregular breathing further distract the citta

These are symptoms that we all experience from time to time and they prevent concentration and focus. This is where we have to take care of day to day activities by taking care of our physical body with movement, our associations with others and with our forms of entertainment, diet and rest. We should not allow the body and mind to be tamasic (heavy and dull). They should always be in a sattvic (balanced and light) condition This cannot be created all of a sudden. We always have to take care of these things in our daily life. A sickly body can never be fit to sit; it will not allow the mind to meditate quietly. Weak nerves will always cause tremors. When some people meditate, they tremble an perspire. These are symptoms of physical weakness. But such things will not happen if we keep our body in proper condition by right diet, exercise, proper rest and if we do not allow it to become lazy and dull.

Y.S. 1.32 Tatpratisedhartham ekatattva abhyasah

Tatpratisedhartham – for their prevention
eka – one, single
tattva – a real state, reality, truth
abhyasah – practice

Adherence to single-minded effort prevents these impediments.

The point here is that we should not keep changing our object of concentration. When you decide on one thing, stick to it no matter what happens. There’s no value in digging shallow wells in a hundred places. Decide on one place and dig deep. Even if you encounter a rock, use dynamite and keep going down. If you leave that to dig another well, all the first effort is wasted and there is no proof you won’t hit rock again. Before you start digging, analyze well. And find out which spot is good. Then, once you decide and begin, you should not question it further. Go right at it, because it will be too late then to think whether it is worthwhile or not; you should have done that before.

Even if it is a long route, your perseverance will make it short. Our aim is to make the mind steady, so it is immaterial which object we take. Anything can take you to the goal, because you are not concentrating on the object for the sake of the object but for the sake of your goal. We should always remember this: all of our ideas, objects or even mantras are just symbols to hold onto as aids towards the goal. Behind the objects you should always remember the goal.

Tastes, temperaments and capacities differ, so you should not criticize another person’s object of meditation because you have selected another. He is approaching the same goal through his object. Just as you have confidence in your object, he too has that confidence in his way. We should not disturb the other person’s faith, nor let ourselves get distracted from our faith. Stick to one thing and forge ahead with that. Why should we have this one-pointed concentration? To make the mind clear so you can transcend it. You are not going to cling to the object but just use it as a ladder to climb up. Once you have reached the roof, leave the ladder behind.

For those of you who are interested in the texts I have been using, I base my commentary on The Yoga Sutras from a combination of several texts and one app:

The Heart of Yoga by T.K.V. Desikachar
Light on The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by B.K.S. Iyengar
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Edwin F. Bryant
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Swami Satchidananda
And an app on the Yoga Sutras developed by Daniel Levine

Yoga Sutras 1.25 – 1.28 The Sutras on Objective Enlightment

Y.S. 1.25 Tatra nitratisayam sarvajna bijam
tatra - there in (God)
niratisayam - unrivalledsarvajna - all knowledge
bijam - seed, an origin In that consciousness there is the seed of all unsurpassed knowledge.

In the previous sutra I used the illustration of a circle drawn on a piece of paper. The circle represents the finite. This is also a representation of us, a single person, drawn out of the infinite that surrounds us. In order for us to be finite, and each one of us different, there must be an infinite around us. In this infinity (god, or supreme consciousness) there is infinte time, space and knowledge.

Y.S. 1.26 Sa esa purvesam api guruh kalena anavacchedat
sa - that
esa - Purusha or God
purvesam - first, foremsot
api - also
guruh - master, teacher
kalena - time
anavacchedat - unbounded, unlimited
In the very beginning there were also teachers since truth is not limited by time.

Y.S. 1.27 Tasya vacakah pranavah
tasya -Him
vacakah - signifying
pranavah - the sacred syllable AUM
Of this, we refer to the entire experience as AUM. (pranavah translates literally to humming)
This refers to the practice of chanting.

Y.S. 1.28 Taj japa tadhartha bhavanam
taj - that
japah - muttering in an undertone, whispering, repeating
tadarthabhavanam - its aim, purpose, identification Repetitive chanting of the Name will lead to a deeper meaning.
When you listen to “yoga music” you are listening to songs that are really chants extolling the virtues of god, by using the various names for god: Shiva, Brahma, Vishnu, Ganesha, Saraswati, Kali, Durga, etc… Krishna Das, one of the most well known kirtan singers, began as a devotee in India, sitting at his guru’s feet chanting the holy name, trying to reach enlightenment.

In the chant “Om Namah Shivaya” The Om is that humming. Everything is contained in that Om as it is said to vibrate inside of us tuning us to the same vibration of the universe, infinite or god. The word Namah means I bow to. It comes from the same route as Namaste. Shiva is one of the names of god, but the “ya” on the end is reflexive, turning it back into yourself. So, Shivaya refers to that aspect of god, Shiva, the infinite, that resides inside of you.

While many people make pilgrimages to holy lands and special teachers, the real journey is into the inner self. To touch that divine spark inside of your own Self.

"We shall not cease from exploration. And the end of all our exploring will be to arrive where we started and know the place for the first time." – T.S. Eliot, Little Gidding

A scientific note about Om:*

“It is recently reported that the Earth undergoes free oscillations with a period of between 150 and 500 seconds, as determined from an analysis of seismic data. The most probable force driving this bell-like ringing of the Earth arises from variations in atmospheric pressure alternately pressing inward and outward on the Earth’s surface. Note that though we speak of this ringing of the Earth as a “sound” it is at far too low a frequency (2-7 millihertz) to be heard by the middle ear, which has a low frequency cut-off of 20 hertz. In several experiments people do report “shivers down their spines” when exposed to sound waves below the 20-hertz cut-off; however, it is not clear that the sensations involve the ears. Is it possible that these two scientific discoveries have anything to do with the sound of the universe as reported in the yoga texts as the all-permeating “Om” when in deeply meditative states?

For those of you who are interested in the texts I have been using, I base my commentary on The Yoga Sutras from a combination of several texts and one app:
The Heart of Yoga by T.K.V. Desikachar
Light on The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by B.K.S. Iyengar
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Edwin F. Bryant
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Swami Satchidananda
And an app on the Yoga Sutras developed by Daniel Levine

*A Handbook for Yogasana Teachers: The Incorporation of Neuroscience, Physiology and Anatomy into the Practice. Mel Robin

Yoga Sutras Ch1. 21 - 24 The Effects of Effort and Surrender to God.

These first two sutras are still about our efforts  and their effects towards the goal of yoga.

Y.S. 1. 21  Tivra samveganam asannah
The rate of our progress is relative to the rate at which we practice and our enthusiasm for the work.

Y.S. 1. 22  Mrdu madhya adhimatravat tato’pi visesah
The various forms of devotion are mild, middle and intense. The more intense the faith, the closer the goal.

The next couple of sutras talk about devotion to a higher power.  These can be difficult for a lot of people because the word god (ishvara) is used.  This is not the same god, or being, of Christianity or Judaism.  Ishvara is more of a primordial source, a state of consciousness from which everything in the universe emanates, a state of “is-ness” called Purusha in Sanskrit.

Swami Satchidananda explains god this way:  “In other words, he is all knowing.  He is knowledge itself.  The cosmic knowledge is called the supreme soul or purusha.  How can we imagine or visualize it?  Imagine a circle.  You can see the space within it nd the space outside it.  The inner space is finite and the outer is infinite.  If you accept the existence of a finite space you have to accept an infinite one.  Without infinite there can be no finite.  The moment you say, “I am a man,” there must be a woman.  If you say “left” there must be a right.  The thought of one implies the thought of the other.  We feel that our minds are limited and finite.  So, there must be a source of infinite knowledge beyond that. “

Y.S. 1. 23  Isvara pranidhanad va
Devotion and surrendering to a higher power will lead to Samadhi

Patanjali recognizes that attempt to change our mind to a state of yoga is fraught with obstacles that vary in potency.  But for those who have either an inborn faith in god (ishvara) or are able to develop it over the years, the state of yoga can be achieved.

Y.S. 1. 24 – Klesa karma vipaka asayaaih aparamrstah purusa visesa isvarah
Consciousness is not affected by causes, reactions, pain or karma (Hint – but our ego is!)  I’ll talk more about this in the next group of sutras.

Yoga Sutras on Perception and the Effects of Effort

Y.S. 1.17 Vitarka vichara ananda asmita rupa anugamat samprajnatah
Practice and detachment develop four types of Samadhi: self-analysis, synthesis, bliss and the experience of pure being.

Y.S. 1.18  Virama pratyaya abhyasa purvah samskara seso nyah
When the mind rises to this state of yoga and remains so, the usual mental disturbances are absent.  However, memories of the past continue.

Patanjali lets us know that it is only possible to reach higher levels of yoga through the various stages of practice.  First comes concentration and meditation.  One learns to meditate on the grosser elements before being able to contemplate the subtler elements.  The mind must achieve one-pointed-ness and have been brought under complete control in order to reach the state of Samadhi.

This constitutes an understanding of the order of the universe from the formless state of consciousness to the solid state of the physical world.  The path to Samadhi starts by contemplating the physical and works back to the state of pure consciousness.

Y.S. 1. 19  Bhava pratyayo videha prakriti layanam
Inevitable because of the many millions who share the world with us there will be some who are born in a state of yoga.  They need not practice or discipline themselves.

Y.S. 1. 20  Sraddha virya smrti Samadhi prajna purvaka itaresam
But what of the rest of us?  Is there really a chance of achieving this state of yoga?  Through faith, which will give sufficient energy to achieve success against all odds, direction will be maintained.  The realization of the goal of yoga is a matter of time.

Yoga Sutras 12 – 16 – The Sutras on Practice and Non-Attachment

Practice and Non-Attachment

Patanjali has defined the ways in which our mind takes in the outside world: comprehension, misconception, imagination, deep sleep and memory.  He says that these means of experiencing the outside world can be painful or painless; painful when we are deceived by our own minds and painless when we can see beyond these states of mind and recognize them for what they are.

How do we know if we perceive something correctly and are not being tricked my memory, imagination, sleepiness or misunderstanding?  By practicing:

Y.S. I.12 Abhyasa vairagyabhyam tannirodah
The mind can reach the state of yoga through practice and detachment.

Y.S. I.13  Tatra sthitau yatnah abhyasah
Practice is the steadfast effort to still these fluctuations.

Y.S. I.14 Sa ta dirgakala nairantarya satkara asevitah drdhabhumih
This practice, performed for a long time, without interruption and with sincere devotion will become the rock you stand on.

There will always be a tendency to start practice with enthusiasm, energy and a desire for sudden results.  But the continuing pressures of everyday life and the enormous resistance of the mind encourages us to succumb to human weaknesses.  All of this is understandable, we all have these tendencies.  These sutras emphasize the need to approach practice soberly with a positive, self-disciplined attitude and with a long-term view towards eventual success.  (Remember the Malcom Gladwell book on mastery and how it takes 10,000 hours.)

Y.S. I.15  Drishta anusravika visaya vitrsnasya vasikara samjna vairagyam
Mastery is attained when even things read in scriptures are consciously let go of.

Y.S. I.16  Tatparam purusa khyateh guna vaitrsnyam
The purest consciousness is one that reflects indifference to the most subtle qualities.

This last sutra points to the addiction of the material world and it encourages us to practice our detachment to it.  It is our preferences to pull in the things that we like and to push away the things we don’t like that create a painful state.

I was recently at an ashram enjoying a morning of chanting, meditation and satsang.  After the session we were invited to stay for chai and cake.  There was some complaining among the ashramites on the taste of the chai.  One preferred a lot of ginger and the other preferred less ginger.  A wise voice from the corner of the room chimed in, “The amount of spice in the chai is already there.  The choice is to drink the chai or not to drink the chai.”  Ah!  If it were only as simple as not drinking the chai!  But not complaining about the chai is a good example of how the mind works.

There will always be reasons to not practice, or to complain about the practice:  illness, injury, job or family circumstances will pull us away.  But we are encouraged to get back on track as soon as we can.  When I broke my foot, I did a lot of arm yoga.  When I broke my wrist, I did a lot of work on my legs.  There is always something to work on.  And it is important to celebrate what we have and can do as opposed to what we may have lost or can’t do.  And while Patanjali is talking about the mind here, you cannot separate the mind from the body as the nerves reach to all parts of the body.  The two are inter-connected.

The role of the mind is one of the most important things to consider in your practice.  When I don’t practice, I often find my mind making excuses:  I’m too tired, I don’t have time, I have to do this first, … When I do exert tapas (effort) to get to my mat and practice, whether I feel like it or not, I end up having a great practice;  I just had to get past my mind.  When there is that inevitable hiatus, for whatever reason, it is important to cultivate patience and beginner’s mind.  Our tendency is to call upon memory and tell ourselves that we used to be able to do something and so we should be able to do that now.  It is easy to injure yourself coming back to practice that way.   I’ve heard a rule of thumb that helps me be patient when beginning again and that is to allow two days  for every one day off.  And while it is true that you have to be careful to not let your ego get in the way when you start again, no progress is ever truly lost.  While I used to bemoan any injury I had as a set-back, I have come to realize, that over the long term, I have spent much less time being injured than I have not being injured.  And that my practice, when consistent is stronger than ever.

Finally, I’d like you to consider this quote from Henry Ford as you think about the role your mind has in your practice:  “Whether you think you can or you think you can’t, you will be right.”  It doesn’t guarantee immediate results, but over a long period of time, without interruption, it can become the rock you stand on!

The Yoga Sutras on The Architecture of the Mind

The Architecture of the Mind

These are the five kinds of thought forms, or vrttis,  that we must be aware of and be able to see them for what they are in order to be able to find inner peace.  Knowing this, the next question is:  How do we recognize these vrttis?  We need to recognize what they are before we can be able to control them.   Otherwise our thoughts take on the form of the world around us, harden like clay, and you presume that they are you.

The five thought forms are:

Y.S. I.6  Pramana viparyaya vikalpa nidra smrtayah
The five activities are right knowledge, misconception, imagination, deep sleep and memory.

These five activities of the mind are in action in every moment and all at the same time.  For example, the thought of “home” will be perceived in shades of its actuality (pramana), its incorrect assumption of permanence (viparyaya), our fantasies of its future (vikalpa), the memories we’ve had within it (smrtayah) and the void of its non-existence (nidra).  Knowing that our thoughts can be colored by these five characteristics can help us identify true perception (pramana) among the others.  The goal is not necessarily to see the truth exclusively, but to be able to distinguish it.

For those of you who are interested in the texts I have been using, I base my commentary on The Yoga Sutras from a combination of several texts and one app:

The Heart of Yoga by T.K.V. Desikachar
Light on The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by B.K.S. Iyengar
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Edwin F. Bryant
The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali by Swami Satchidananda
And an app on the Yoga Sutras developed by Daniel Levine

Yoga Sutras I.5 – I.11 - Definition of the Vrttis of the Mind

Definition of Vrttis of the Mind

I have read that we have somewhere around 60,000 thoughts a day and that 80% of those thoughts are repetitive. Of those repetitive thoughts, 80% are negative! I found that statistic to be rather amazing and somewhat disheartening. These thoughts create our reality and our suffering or lack of suffering. Yoga teaches us that we can do something about these thoughts, that we can become aware of the activities of our mind and that we can do something about these negative thoughts.

But first Patanjali has to define exactly what the mind is before we can learn how to control it. He defines the mind as the activities (vrttis) that occupy it.

Y.S. I.5 Vrttayah pancatayyah klistah aklistah
There are five activities of the mind. Each of them can be beneficial and each can cause problems.

Y.S. I.6 Pramana viparyaya vikalpa nidra smrtayah
The five activities are right knowledge, misconception, imagination, deep sleep and memory.

The activities, or vrttis, are each defined:

Y.S. I.7 Pratyaksa anumana agamah pramanani
Right knowledge is based on direct observation of the object, inference and reference to reliable sources.

Y.S. I.8 Viparyayo mithya-jnanam atad rupa pratistham
Misconception occurs when knowledge of something is not based on its true form.

Y.S. I.9 Sabda jnana anupati vastu-sunyo vikalpah
Imagination is the comprehension of an object based only on words and expressions even though the object is absent.

Y.S. I.10 Abhava pratyaya alambana tamo vrtti nidra
Deep sleep is when the mind is overcome with heaviness and no other activities are present.

Y.S. I.11 Anubhuta visaya asampramosah smrtih
Memory is the mental retention of a conscious experience.

These are the five kinds of vrttis, or thought forms, that we must be aware of and be able to see them for what they are in order to be able to find inner peace. Knowing this, the next question should be how to control these vrttis, because in reality, they seem to be controlling us.